Following the decision to close Bonner House by May this year, target reporter Claire Farrow visited the home to see how its residents have reacted to the news...
WHEN you first walk into Bonner House you would be forgiven for thinking it was a social gathering where people of a similar age meet up - but that is where you are wrong.
To the residents and visitors, it is so much more than that.
It is a home and a place of safety where they know all their needs will be met with staff who go out of their way to make the residents as comfortable and happy as possible.
At the home I was welcomed by residents who were keen to share their views and were all desperate to save such an important part of their community.
However, Lincolnshire County Council is saying that people using the home are being reassured that a range of other high-quality, local options are now available.
As it works towards modernising and personalising care provision in Lincolnshire, the authority's executive decided last July that the homes would close, but only when it was satisfied that suitable alternative provision was available.
Councillor Graham Marsh, executive member for adult social care, said: "With a rapidly growing elderly population, providing the best possible care for our residents is an absolute priority for the council.
"By closing three outdated and expensive homes and replacing them with access to an improved menu of care options, we hope residents can see how we're meeting this priority."
The council also claims it has found more job vacancies in similar fields than the number of staff that could be made redundant from the closure.
When the time came for me to leave Bonner House I walked through the dining room where Marjorie Passfield was eating her lunch along with other residents.
Due to her stroke Marjorie struggles to swallow and began choking.
Thankfully, the staff were on hand and she was ok, but what if she was at home on her own?
Marjorie Passfield, 77
Marjorie joined Bonner House four weeks ago for respite care.
She suffered a stroke which left her unable to speak and communicates through a machine.
She said: "The home means a lot to me as I know it is somewhere safe for me to rest. I will miss the helpful staff so much and believe that the closure is helping to make room for the proposed Tesco store."
Di Cardell, 88
Di has been recovering from a broken hip which would have been slow progress if she were at home.
She said: "I think it is absolutely appalling that the home is to close as the care staff provide extreme care that is beyond anything I have ever experienced before.
"I have no help available from my family so would have to rely on neighbours for the help so will have to wait and see what happens and what is offered to me when Bonner House closes."
Mary Rodgers, 87
Mary is in respite care after cracking her knee cap twice in the last year.
She said: "I am very independent but I know when I need a place like this. The care is second to none and I don't see why, when my generation has helped to fight the war and paid our dues, that we can't get a little something in return."
"Also, I would like to know exactly where these job vacancies are that the council speaks of, because realistically, I can't see there being that many."
Enriqueta King
Enriqueta is the daughter of Mary Rodgers who is currently in respite care.
She said: "There has in no way been enough communication as to what my mum can do next.
"I have tried phoning for answers but have had no response and am getting angrier by the day.
"This place offers me a lot of peace of mind to know my mum is in a safe environment where she has everything she needs, even down to good company and a social life.
"I feel incredibly let down by our authorities and feel bad for the generation who helped to keep Britain's independence being cast aside - it is a disgrace."
Walter Cheffings, 79
Walter is being cared for as he suffers from severe arthritis which has left his feet paralysed.
He said: "We have been left on the shelf as I believe the elderly are just an embarrassment to the council and deemed a waste of money.
"We have done our duty and now we are no longer needed. Without us, councillors wouldn't be where they are today, making silly decisions.
"First close care homes, what next? Fill the swimming pool with goldfish? "It's a disgrace and I can't help but wonder what these decision makers will do when they get old and can no longer get about on their own."
GAYLORD — Richard Bottomley is facing a difficult issue encountered by millions of adult children in the U.S.
His mother, Dorothy, 93, can no longer make her own decisions, and he wants to insure that her final years are comfortable.
About six years ago when his mother first exhibited signs of dementia, Bottomley moved her from the Alpine Alten Zimmer apartments to an Adult Foster Care (AFC) home.
“I moved her to Rocking Chair Home Care, Bottomley said. “It is licensed for four residents, and it’s a family-type setting. Clients and staff eat together, and my mother is able to have her own room. The owner is an LPN (licensed practical nurse).”
The cost for residing in the home was $1,900 per month initially, but it has risen to $2,500 as her condition required more services.
Bottomley, however, feels the price is well worth it.
“She’s happy and gets good care,” he said. “There is a large living room where the residents can sit with 15 bird feeders outside the window and a huge TV set and aquarium inside. When she first moved in I’d take her out to dinner a couple times a week, but as the dementia progressed, it would make her anxious and she’d fret about where we were going. She wanted to be home where she felt safe.”
As his mother’s guardian, Bottomley realized recently that she would run out of her savings within a year and would need to go on Medicaid. He has researched and found that it would be easier to place her in a nursing home where Medicaid will pay an average of $6,618 rather than keep her at the AFC home where she is thriving.
He feels the move to a nursing home would be traumatic to his mother. She wouldn’t be able to have her own room and there would be a lower ratio of staff to clients to provide services. It also would cost taxpayers far more money, which doesn’t make sense to him in these difficult economic times.
Although some seniors require the services provided by nursing homes, and Dorothy may at some point, professionals who provide direct care agree that the move can be quite traumatic for many seniors.
Laurie Sauer is the director of the Area Agency on Aging Region 9, which covers Otsego County. According to her, there are some programs that could help Bottomley’s mother stay in the AFC home under certain circumstances, but funds are limited.
“We are supportive of community–based options that help people stay in place,” Sauer said. “There are programs like Michigan’s MI Choice that can arrange a Medicaid waiver for AFC homes. Unfortunately, there is a huge waiting list.”
While room and board is included in Medicaid’s payments to nursing homes, that cost is not covered for those residing in AFC homes. Only documented services are paid. Many people would be unable to cover the costs of room and board at an AFC placement.
Ruth Jose, owner of the Rocking Chair Home Care Center, has begun the long process of applying for Medicaid eligibility and worries about the additional hours she’ll have to spend documenting every minute of the services she provides. She also worries about the many elderly who won’t be able to afford the room and board.
“I charge $1,700 to $2,500 a month, depending on services,” Jose said.”I can’t tell you how many times someone wanted to move into my home, but their income was only around $800. They had to go to a nursing home instead. It’s heart wrenching.”
How to keep costs down and the frail elderly safe and comfortable in their community has become a national discussion as the aging population increases.
A story in the New York Times reported that some states have been experimenting with programs since the early 1980s that make foster care more available. The newspaper contacted aging experts and AFC staff and residents in five of those states and the conclusion was that the programs were extremely successful economically and in terms of the residents’ well-being.
Some of the elderly paid for their own foster care and some had their care paid by Supplemental Security Income. Some states had received waivers from the federal government to use Medicaid long-term nursing funds for the AFC homes.
Legislative committees in Lansing are currently examining the issue of elder residential services and are looking for input. Bottomley has written a letter he intends to send to his representatives at the state and federal levels. Others with an opinion on the subject are encouraged to do the same.











